September 8 – State of
Being at Death
Philippians 1:21-23:
"For me, to live is Christ and to die is gain. If I am to live
in the flesh, this means fruitful labor for me; I do not know which I
prefer. I am hard-pressed between the two; my desire is to depart
and to be with Christ, for that is far better."
Some Christians believe
that after bodily death, the spirits of these same people are in a
state of sleep until the end of time when a resurrection will occur
in order to have a final judgment. I believe that those who believe
in this have arrived at this conclusion partly because of the
metaphorical word "sleep", which is used by Jesus and Paul
to refer to physical death.
In Mark 5:21-43, we have
the story of Jesus raising the daughter of Jairus from the dead. In
verse 35, we are clearly told that the girl was physically dead,
which prompted the messengers to question bothering Jesus any
further. Nonetheless, Jesus tells Jairus to not fear but to believe.
When they arrive at the house of Jairus, Jesus asks why the mourners
were making such a commotion, when the girl was "not dead but
asleep". She was clearly dead, and Jesus was not refuting that
claim, but simply using a metaphor. He really did make her spirit
come back into a dead body.
In John 11, we have the
story of raising Lazarus from the dead. In verses 11-14 we read, "
'Our friend Lazarus has fallen asleep, but I am going there to awaken
him.' The disciples said to him, 'Master, if he has fallen asleep,
he will be alright.' Jesus had been speaking about his death, but
they thought that he was referring merely to sleep. Then Jesus told
them plainly, 'Lazarus is dead.' " Jesus clearly uses the terms
of physical death and sleep interchangeably.
Paul also does the same
thing in 1 Corinthians 15, which is his lengthy discourse on the
future resurrection of the physical body. In verse 6 he contrasts
the state of two different groups: those who are still alive and those
who have fallen asleep. In the context of his discourse, "fallen
asleep" has to mean physical death. He uses the same language
in verses 18 and 20.
None of the previous
three examples, however, disprove the concept of soul sleep, because
they are all referencing physical death. As Christians, we believe
that at physical death, the spirit departs the body and goes
elsewhere. Where does it go, and what is its state of being?
Before we can answer the
question of where a departed spirit lives, we have to think about
what a spirit is. Christians believe that there are only three major
types of spirits – God, angels/demons, and people's. Spirits are
other-worldly, inter-dimensional beings that can live apart from the
physical world that we feel and experience every day as "living"
entities. That physical world can be seen, felt, heard, smelled in
the space of width, length, depth, and time. Any other dimensions
that exist would be considered in some way as spiritual
(metaphysical). The Bible does refer to spiritual places as seeming
to be physically located, although I believe that this reference is
only to help us humans to grasp the reality of a spiritual dimension,
which does not need a physical place to exist. One passage that gives
a glimpse into the physical references of the "grave" and
its opposite term "heaven" is in Ephesians 4, where Paul
quotes part of Psalm 68. He refers to Jesus descending to the lower
parts of the earth and then ascending far above all the heavens.
Lets break this down into specifics.
The concept of the
afterlife in the Old Testament is nebulous at best. Many ancient
cultures believed in an afterlife of sorts, which is why the dead
were sometimes buried with personal belongings. The departed spirit
needed some things in order to live well in the next life. We get
some mixed thoughts from the Old Covenant on this idea. David states
in Psalm 6:5, "For in death there is no remembrance of you; who
can give you praise in Sheol?" One could infer from this the
idea of "soul sleep", because David recognizes a place for
departed spirits, but implies that they may "know nothing".
Psalm 30:9 and Isaiah 38:18 also echo this sentiment. David
furthermore predicts a resurrection from this state in Psalm 15:10,
where he states that "you will not abandon me to Sheol".
This line is also referenced by Peter in Acts 2:27, as he talked
about Jesus dying and resurrecting. David furthermore states in
Psalm 17:15 that "when I awake, I shall be satisfied in seeing
your likeness." These verses alone could make a good argument
for "soul sleep".
From here, though, let
us look at the transliterated word above – Sheol. This Hebrew word
is often translated as "hell", "hades", or "the
grave". The closer word to the concept in English is "grave",
but it is not referring to a physical piece of dirt in which a dead
body is laid. It means the "abode of the dead". This
simple definition is a general term without reference to the home of
the righteous or the unrighteous.
In 1 Samuel 28, King Saul
is in desperate straits to know the will of God, who has been silent
on giving him direction. Saul disguises himself and goes to a
medium, intending on speaking with the dead, specifically with the
great prophet Samuel, who had recently died. (I personally believe
this event to be a one-off occurrence allowed by God, and not a
general possibility of contacting dead spirits, which was forbidden
by God in Deuteronomy 18:11.) In 1 Samuel 28:15, the departed spirit
of Samuel indeed speaks to Saul, saying, "Why have you disturbed
me by bringing me up?" The Hebrew word here that is translated
as "disturbed" has nothing to do with being asleep. It has
a simple meaning of "being agitated or shaken". Samuel did not imply
that he was asleep and then aroused from sleep. He was simply in a
state of consciousness. Interestingly, he tells Saul that "tomorrow,
you and your sons shall be with me." There is no
differentiation between the righteous and the unrighteous, if we
assume that Samuel was on the side of righteousness, and that Saul
was on the side of unrighteousness (seeing that God had "forsaken"
him as king, since his heart was not fully committed). That is an
assumption that I am not really endorsing, nor is it relevant for
this topic. What is relevant is the fact that Samuel was conscious.
Jesus gives us the best
picture that we have for the depiction of Sheol or "hades",
since his story was written in Greek. Hades is the direct Greek
correlation to "Sheol". In Luke 16:19-21, Jesus tells the
story of the unnamed rich man and the named paralytic Lazarus.
(Apparently, Lazarus was a common name of that time, and should not be confused with the Lazarus of Bethany, whom Jesus raised from the
dead. I also do not believe that this story was simply a parable,
because Jesus named Lazarus specifically, whereas there are no names
associated with people in all of his other parables.) When Lazarus
dies, he is "carried" to Abraham's side, which was a place
of "comfort", as Abraham mentions. The rich man is in
torment not far from where Abraham and Lazarus are, but which is
separated by a great chasm. Here we have the delineation of the
righteous and the unrighteous in Sheol – one in torment and one in
comfort. Both are conscious and not sleeping.
Jesus also gives us one
more glimpse of the afterlife before his resurrection. While dying
on the cross, he replies to the repentant fellow executee on his
cross, "today you will be with me in paradise". This is
almost a parallel of what Samuel had told King Saul. Why would it
matter to tell someone that any type of paradise would await him, if
he would never enjoy it bu t simply be asleep? That makes no sense,
to tease someone with bliss, then to never let him enjoy that bliss.
After all, when one is asleep, there is no enjoyment (or torment, for
that matter) experienced or felt.
While it is not
explicitly described in the New Testament, the following is what I
believe to have occurred during the days of Jesus' physical death.
Jesus makes a visit to the "tormented" side of Sheol to
proclaim judgment to the unrighteous, either human or demonic, as
hinted at in 1 Peter 3:20. (The arguments for, or against, such are
outside the scope of this writing.) He then takes the horde of people
who are with Abraham in "paradise", and "ascends"
to Heaven with them to be with the Father. This is referenced in the
aforementioned passage of Paul in Ephesians 4:7-10. None of this
activity could have happened if Jesus was asleep in his temporary
death.
One other passage in the
New Testament puts these ideas together within the puzzle. In John
14, Jesus states that he is about to return to the Father, who
happens to be in Heaven (Matthew 6:9). Sometimes Heaven (the
spiritual dimension) seems to be portrayed as "in the heavens"
in the New Testament. These instances are often translated as such,
almost interchangeably, since the Greek word used for each reference
is only one word: "ouranois". This word is mostly used
with an article as well, if only for the simple reason of proper
Greek grammar: "tois ouranois", the heavens. The context
of the passage usually helps us to distinguish between the cosmos
(physical space) and an other-dimensional place where we conceive of
the Father "residing". Jesus states that he would come
back and take the disciples to be where he and the Father would be.
Finally, when we add the
statement of Paul in Philippians 1 (stated above in the preamble), we
get a picture of one enjoying fellowship with the entities of the
Trinity, not a non-experiential state of unconsciousness). 1
Thessalonians 4:17,18 also agrees with this sentiment: "...so
we will be with the Master forever. Therefore, encourage one another
with these words." I personally can't see how encouraging it
would be to look forward to centuries of sleep, only to be awakened
to a positive judgment, even one that is totally blissful with no
pain or sorrow, and even if centuries of sleep would only feel like
one second had elapsed at the awakening.
One other idea needs to
be addressed as well. The previous scripture mentioned – 1
Thessalonians 4 – is a reference to "the rapture", which
is also mentioned in Matthew 24. This rapture entails the
resurrection of bodies for the spirits of saved individuals. If
bodies are then re-united with spirits, does Jesus take them all back
to a Heaven, that was previously prepared for only spirits? There
are now glorified bodies involved in a possible other-dimensional
place that is NOT mentioned specifically in either 1 Thessalonians 4 or Matthew
24. Another possibility is that at this "gathering" the
glorified bodies will now live on the current earth, or that the "new
heavens and earth" will now begin. In both passages, we are left
hanging with the idea of "what happens next?" That answer
(of end-time events) is outside the scope of this argument. While
the possibility of "soul sleep" might seem plausible to
some, I cannot see it as a logical possibility for believers who are
meant to experience life to the full (John 10:10), no matter what
dimension we are in.